57th Street Menus
Dine-In OR To Go
A TRADITIONAL FEAST WITH ALL THE TRIMMINGS
$40 (Excluding Tax & Gratuity)
Download PDFMain Course
-
Free-Range Herb-Roasted Turkey
brioche stuffing, noodle kugel, haricot verts almondine, cranberry chtuney, giblet gravy
(dark meat is available upon request)
Dessert
Traditional Pecan PieTo Go Orders must be received by Friday November 20th at 12pm
Orders will be available for pick up on Thursday November 26th between 10:30am-12pmWine Pairing
-
Red
Pinot Noir, 2016 J Vineyards (California) USA
$35
Eggs & Omelettes*
all served with crispy corn polentaavocado - 3.95
-
Freshly squeezed orange juice $4.95
-
Three Eggs Any Style
choice of challah bread or everything bagel
$15.95
with applewood smoked bacon $20.95
with housemade Italian sausage $20.95
with nova smoked salmon $21.95
-
Eggs Benedict
with applewood smoked bacon $21.95
with housemade Italian sausage $21.95
with nova smoked salmon $22.95
-
Avocado Toast with Poached Eggs & Feta Cheese
$18.95
nova smoked salmon $5.95
-
Vegetable Frittata Omelette
choice of challah bread or everything bagel
$19.95
-
THE OMELETTE
bacon, tillamook cheddar, fines herbes, & choice of challah bread or everything bagel
$18.95
-
Egg White "Vernon Brown" Omelette
oyster mushrooms, feta cheese, spinach, tomatoes & choice of challah bread or everything bagel
$18.95
Brooklyn Diner Classics
Gluten Free Biscuit - 3.00-
Tony Bennett’s Famous Thick-Cut Cinnamon, Raisin & Pecan French Toast
fresh strawberries & all-natural maple syrup
$21.95
-
Nova Scotia Smoked Salmon & Scrambled Eggs
crispy corn polenta, choice of challah or everything bagel
$21.95
-
Pastrami Hash with Two Fried Eggs
$23.95
-
Our Famous Noodle Kugel Breakfast
fage brand yogurt, fresh strawberries & blueberries, toasted walnuts, honey
$18.95
-
Huevos Rancheros
grilled tortilla, eggs, chorizo, housemade Italian sausage, pico de gallo
$20.95
Pancakes & Waffles
served with all-natural, pure maple syrup-
Old Fashioned Buttermilk Pancakes
$18.95
-
Old Fashioned Buttermilk Pancakes Topped with Fresh Strawberries
$19.95
-
Maine Blueberry Buttermilk Pancakes
candied orange zest
$19.95
-
Fresh Strawberry Waffles
whipped cream
$19.95
-
Nutella Chocolate Hazelnut Waffles
fresh banana, hazelnuts crumbles, whipped cream
$19.95
-
Fruit & Nut Granola & Fage Yogurt
with fresh strawberries, blueberries & banana
$14.95
-
Steelcut Oatmeal
with fresh strawberries & banana
$11.95
Bagel Tower Sandwiches
gluten free biscuit - 3.00, almond cream cheese - 2.00-
Smoked Salmon Bagel
everything bagel, cream cheese, tomato, bibb lettuce, cucumber salad
$21.95
-
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Bagel
everything bagel, tillamook cheddar cheese, spicy mayo, crispy corn polenta
$19.75
-
Egg & Cheese Bagel
everything bagel, tillamook cheddar cheese, spicy mayo, crispy corn polenta
$18.95
Sides
We serve applewood smoked, nitrate-free bacon-
Applewood Smoked Bacon
$7.95
-
Housemade Italian Sausage
$7.95
-
Crispy Corn Polenta
pomodoro sauce
$5.95
-
Our Famous Noodle Kugel
$7.95
add a piece to any dish $5.95
Yogurt Breakfast
-
ALL INCLUDED
Freshly squeezed orange juice
Bowl of Fage Yogurt
Fruit and nut granola
Fresh Strawberries, Blueberries, & Bananas
Coffee or espresso or tea$19.95
New Yorker Breakfast
-
ALL INCLUDED
Freshly squeezed orange juice
Three eggs any style
Your choice of: applewood smoked bacon, housemade chicken sausage, homemade Italian sausage, pastrami hash +3.95, nova smoked salmon +3.95
Crispy corn polenta & pomodoro sauce
Your choice of: everything bagel, croissant +4.95
Coffee or espresso or tea$26.95
The Best Milkshakes in Town
$12.00-
Vanilla Milkshake
-
Chocolate Fudge Milkshake
-
Oreo Cookie & Vanilla Milkshake
The Real Original Egg Cream
$7.95-
Chocolate
-
Vanilla
Cakes & Cookies
New York Magazine: "The house's strawberry blonde cheesecake is worth a month on your treadmill."-
The Strawberry Blonde Cheesecake
strawberries, valrhona fudge
$12.95
-
Our Classic New York Cheesecake
$11.95
-
Allen Grubman's Chocolate Blackout Cake
triple-layered valrhona chocolate cake & chocolate ganache frosting
$12.75
-
Traditional Rugelach
chocolate, raspberry, apple-pineapple
$10
-
Six-Inch Chocolate Chip Cookie
$6.95
Beverages
A MUST-HAVE: our Belgian hot chocolate topped with an oversized housemade marshmallow.-
Hottie Hot Chocolate
belgian dark chocolate, cocoa, milk, giant marshmallow
$5.50
-
Coffee
$3.95
-
Espresso
$3.95
-
Cappuccino
$4.95
-
Latte
$4.95
-
Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice
$4.95
$6.95
-
Tea
Earl Gray, English Breakfast, Green Tea, Chamomile
$4.95
-
Pellegrino Water
$4.50
-
Fiji Water
$4.50
-
Boylan Soda
Black Cherry, Root Beer, Diet Root Beer
$4.75
-
Mexican Coca Cola
with real cane sugar
$4.50
Appetizers
-
Our Famous Chicken Soup with Plenty of Chicken & Egg Noodles
$12.50
-
Our Famous Matzo Ball Soup with Plenty of Chicken
$13.50
-
Bowl of Chili
tillamook cheddar, onion, sour cream
$13.50
-
Quinoa Salad
avocado, cucumber, radish, currants, orange
$9.75
-
Avocado, Arugula, Romaine Lettuce & Oranges
$10.25
-
Hummus Plate
cucumbers, heirloom carrots, pita
$10.50
-
Buffalo Chicken Wings
$14.50
-
Guacamole & Tortilla Chips
$10.50
-
Chili Nachos
tillamook cheddar, onions, jalapeno, pico de gallo, tortilla chips
$14.50
Entrée Salads
add a cup of chicken soup or split pea soup to any dish $4.95-
The Perfect Plate
quinoa salad, little gem salad, hummus, marinated feta cheese
$19.50
with half avocado $3.95
with chicken paillard $7.95
with blackened salmon $8.75
-
Brooklyn Chicken Salad
napa cabbage, red cabbage, snow peas, edamame, cucumber, seaweed, pickled ginger, oranges, marcona almonds, black tobiko, crispy wontons, cilantro
$23.75
Burgers
all burgers served with french fries-
Hamburger
tomato, lettuce, pickle
$18.95
-
Cheeseburger
tillamook cheddar, tomato, lettuce, pickle
$19.75
-
Bacon Cheeseburger Deluxe
tillamook cheddar, tomato, lettuce, pickle
$20.95
-
Old Fashioned Cheeseburger
double patty, velveeta cheese, bacon, pickle
$20.95
-
French Burger
french fried onions, caramelized onion, cognac sauce, mayo
$23.95
-
Chicken Burger
lettuce, tomato, pickle
$19.95
-
Buffalo Chicken Burger
gorgonzola cheese, buffalo hot sauce, pickle
$19.95
-
Veggie Burger
guacamole, tillamook cheddar cheese, tomato, aioli
$17.95
-
Pastrami Reuben Burger
swiss cheese, russian dressing, cole slaw, pickle
$23.95
-
add a cup of chicken soup or split pea soup to any dish
$4.95
Sandwiches & Tacos
our pastrami is cured for 7 days, and smoked with white hickory for 4 hours-
Our Hot Pastrami Sandwich
cole slaw, pickle, on seeded sourdough
$22.95
-
Pastrami Reuben Sandwich
cole slaw, pickle, on seeded sourdough
$23.95
-
Chicken Tacos
pico de gallo, crema, cilantro, guacamole, & tortilla chips
$20.95
-
Cod Fish Tacos
pico de gallo, crema, guacamole & tortilla chips
$22.95
Brooklyn Diner's Famous Hot Dogs
"The Brooklyn Diner Hot Dog is GREAT. An excellent and snappy all-beef hot dog from a secret source, weighs almost a pound..." - The New York Times-
15-Bite Brooklyn Diner All-Beef Frankfurter
housemade juniper sauerkraut, french fries
$21.95
-
Classic Chili Hot Dog
french fries
$23.95
-
Frankfurter Mac n' Cheese
bacon bread crumbs
$22.95
Entrées
-
Chicken Pot Pie
puff pastry crust, baked daily in limited quantities (please excuse if we sell out)
$23.95
-
St. Louis Spare Ribs
french fries, cole slaw
$26.95
-
Pan Seared Teriyaki Salmon
hen of the woods mushrooms, sauteed spinach, wontons
$25.95
-
Pan Seared Blackened Salmon
sauteed peppers, avocado-mint puree
$25.95
-
Rigatoni Pasta alla Vodka
bread crumbs
$21.95
-
Eggplant Parmigiana
$20.50
-
chicken pepperoni parmigiana
$24.95
-
Pollo Cubano
grilled chicken & spanish rice, caramelized onions, pico de gallo, cilantro sauce
$21.95
-
Chicken Burrito
guacamole, cheddar cheese, black beans, saffron rice, crema, pico de gallo, flour tortilla
$19.95
-
Chicken Burrito Bowl
avocado, peppers, onions, cheddar cheese, black beans, saffron rice, crema, pico de gallo, tortilla chips
$19.95
-
Pastrami Mac n' Cheese
$22.95
Sides
-
Our Famous Noodle Kugel
add a piece to any dish 5.95
$7.95
-
Mac n Cheese
$12.50
-
French Fries
rosemary & thyme
$7.95
-
Rigatoni Pomodoro
$12.50
-
Fruit Bowl
$7.95
Breakfast All Day
-
Three Eggs Any Style
crispy corn polenta, choice of challah bread, plain bagel or everything bagel
$15.95
applewood smoked bacon $20.95
housemade italian sausage $20.95
nova smoked salmon $21.95
-
The Omelette
bacon, tillamook cheddar cheese, fines herbes, crispy corn polenta & choice of challah bread, plain bagel or everything bagel
$18.95
-
Pastrami Hash with Two Fried Eggs
$23.95
-
Avocado Toast with Fried Eggs & Feta Cheese
$18.95
nova smoked salmon $5.95
pastrami has $4.95
-
Fresh Strawberry Waffles
whipped cream, maple syrup
$19.95
-
Nutella Chocolate Hazelnut Waffles
fresh banana, hazelnuts crumbles, whipped cream, maple syrup
$19.95
-
Our Famous Noodle Kugel Breakfast
fage brand yogurt, fresh strawberries & blueberries, toasted walnuts, honey
$18.95
Best Milkshakes in Town
-$12.00--
Vanilla Milkshake
-
Chocolate Fudge Milkshake
-
Oreo Cookie & Vanilla Milkshake
The Real Original Egg Cream
7.95-
chocolate
-
Vanilla
Cakes & Cookies
New York Magazine: "The house's strawberry blonde cheesecake is worth a month on your treadmill."-
The Strawberry Blonde™ Cheesecake
strawberries, valrhona fudge
$12.95
-
Pecan Pie
$11.95
-
Allen Grubman's Chocolate Blackout Cake
triple-layered valrhona chocolate cake & chocolate ganache frosting
$12.75
-
Traditional Rugelach
chocolate, raspberry, apple-pineapple
$10
-
Six-Inch Chocolate Chip Cookie
$6.95
Specialty Cocktails
-
Spiced Apple Toddy
bourbon, warm apple cider, pumpkin pie spice, cream, nutmeg
$14
-
Midtown Cooler
tito's vodka, lime blueberries, fentiman's ginger beer
$15
Wines
-
Pinot Grigio
white wine
Glass $12
Bottle $40
-
Sauvignon Blanc
white wine
Glass $14
Bottle $45
-
Chardonnay
white wine
Glass $12
Bottle $40
-
By Ott
Rose
glass $14
bottle $45
-
Malbec
red wine
glass $12
bottle $40
-
Cabernet Sauvignon
glass $15
bottle $55
-
Pinot Noir
glass $14
bottle $45
Draft Beers
16 oz-
Fireman Craft
IPA, New York
$9
-
Stella Artois
Lager, Belgium
$9
-
Budweiser
Lager, MO
$9
-
Zombie Dust
Pale Ale, WA
$10.50
Bottled Beers
-
Beck's
Lager, Germany
$8
-
Alltechs Bourbon Barrel
Ale, KY
$8
-
Allagash White
White, Maine
$8
-
Erdinger
Non-Alcoholic, Germany
$8
Beverages
A MUST-HAVE: our Belgian hot chocolate topped with an oversized housemade marshmallow.-
Hottie Hot Chocolate
belgian dark chocolate, cocoa, milk, giant marshmallow
$5.50
-
Coffee
$3.95
-
Espresso
$3.95
-
Cappuccino
$4.95
-
Latte
$4.95
-
freshly squeezed Orange Juice
$4.95
$6.95
-
Tea
Earl Grey, English Breakfast, Green Tea, Chamomile
$4.95
-
Pellegrino Water
$4.50
-
Fiji Water
$4.50
-
Boylan Soda
Black Cherry, Root Beer, Diet Root Beer
$4.75
-
Mexican Coca Cola
with real cane sugar
$4.50