powered by BentoBox
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

57th Street Menus

Download PDF

Freshly Squeezed Orange Juice

  • $4.95

    $6.95

Brooklyn Diner Classics

  • Tony Bennett’s Famous Housemade Chocolate-Walnut Babka French Toast

    served with fresh strawberries & all-natural maple syrup

    $19.50

  • The Mixed Marriage of Irving & Gina

    two eggs baked in challah toast, housemade italian sausage, marinara sauce, peppers, onions, crispy corn polenta, pomodoro sauce

    $19.95

  • Pastrami Hash with Two Fried Eggs

    crispy corn polenta, pomodoro sauce, english muffin

    $22.95

  • Our Famous Noodle Kugel Breakfast with Sour Cream or Greek Yogurt

    strawberries, blueberries, walnuts, honey

    $15.50

  • Hand-Chopped Smoked Salmon, Caramelized Onions & Scrambled Eggs

    crispy corn polenta, pomodoro sauce, challah, rye, or whole grain toast

    $20.50

  • Smoked Salmon Bagel Tower Sandwich

    everything or regular bagel, cream cheese, bibb lettuce, cucumber, tomato

    $17.95

Eggs & Omelettes*

all eggs come with challah, rye, or whole grain toast

  • Three Eggs Any Style

    crispy corn polenta, pomodoro sauce

    $15.95

    with applewood smoked bacon, canadian bacon, chicken sausage, or housemade italian sausage $18.75

  • Huevos Rancheros

    grilled tortilla, fried eggs, chorizo, housemade italian sausage, pico de gallo, crema, crispy corn polenta, pomodoro sauce

    $18.95

  • The Omelette

    bacon, tillamook cheddar, fine herbs

    $16.95

  • Three Cheese Omelette

    provolone, mozzarella, parmesan

    $16.95

  • Egg White "Vernon Brown" Omelette

    spinach, tomatoes, hen of the woods mushrooms, feta cheese

    $16.95

  • Pastrami Hash Fritatta

    our housemade pastrami is smoked with white hickory for 4 hours

    $19.95

Benedicts*

  • Classic Eggs Benedict

    canadian bacon, hollandaise sauce, english muffin

    $19.95

  • Sausage Eggs Benedict

    housemade italian sausage, hollandaise sauce, english muffin

    $19.95

  • Smoked Salmon Eggs Benedict

    hollandaise sauce, english muffin

    $19.95

Cakes, Pies & Cookies

all cakes served with whipped cream

  • The Strawberry Blonde Cheesecake

    strawberries, valrhona fudge

    $12.95

  • Our Classic New York Cheesecake

    $11.95

  • Our Famous Red Velvet Cheesecake

    $11.95

  • Chocolate Blackout Cake

    triple-layered valrhona chocolate cake & chocolate ganache frosting

    $11.95

  • Allen Grubman's Chocolate Pudding Pie

    rich valrhona chocolate pudding, whipped cream

    $11.95

  • Triple-Layered Coconut Cake

    $11.95

  • 4 Traditional Rugelach

    chocolate, apricot, pineapple, raspberry

    $10

  • Six-Inch Chocolate Chip Cookie

    $5.95

  • Six-Inch Pecan Chocolate Chip Cookie

    $5.95

Beverages

  • Orange Juice

    freshly squeezed

    $4.95

    $6.95

  • Cranberry Juice

    $3.95

    $4.95

  • Coffee

    $3.95

  • Espresso

    $3.95

  • Americano

    $3.95

  • Macchiato

    $3.95

  • Cappuccino

    $4.95

  • Latte

    $4.95

  • Earl Grey

    $4.95

  • English Breakfast

    $4.95

  • Green Tea

    $4.95

  • Chamomile

    $4.95

  • Boylan's Bottled Soda

    black cherry, orange, root beer

    $4.75

The Continental Breakfast

bagel, english muffin, rye, challah, or whole grain toast

  • $13.50

    also with...cream cheese, peanut butter & strawberry jam

    also with...coffee, espresso or tea & a small orange juice

The Perfect Yogurt Breakfast

poached egg, chobani zero-fat yogurt, fresh strawberries, walnuts, shaved almonds, sunflower seeds, ezekiel whole grain toast

  • $14.50

    also with...coffee, espresso or tea & a small orange juice

New Yorker Breakfast

Eggs Any Style with...

  • bacon, canadian bacon, housemade italian sausage, or chicken sausage

    $24.50

    also with...bagel, english muffin, rye, challah, or whole grain toast

    also with...crispy corn polenta & pomodoro dipping sauce

    also with...coffee, espresso or tea & a small orange juice

Waffle & Pancakes

served with freshly whipped cream & all-natural, pure maple syrup

  • Belgian Waffles

    blueberry sauce, strawberries

    $18.95

  • Old Fashioned Buttermilk Pancakes

    pecan butter (by request)

    $16.95

  • Old Fashioned Buttermilk Pancakes Topped with Fresh Strawberries

    $18.95

  • Maine Blueberry Buttermilk Pancakes

    candied orange zest

    $18.95

  • Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Pancakes

    $18.95

Alexis' Healthiest Blueberry Whole Wheat Pancakes

topped with blueberry compote

  • $18.95

Cereals

  • McCann's Steel Cut Oatmeal

    fresh strawberries & bananas, all-natural maple syrup

    $11.95

  • Granola

    fresh strawberries, bananas, dried fruit

    $12.95

Sides & Toast

  • Applewood Smoked Bacon

    $7.95

  • Housemade Italian Sausage

    pomodoro sauce

    $7.95

  • Canadian Bacon

    $7.95

  • Twin Tokyo Chicken Sausage

    $7.95

  • Muffin in a Mug!

    warm housemade blueberry-corn muffin, whipped cinnamon cream cheese, blueberry sauce

    $5.95

  • Everything Bagel with Cream Cheese, Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam

    (regular bagel available)

    $5.95

  • Gluten-Free Bread with Cream Cheese, Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam

    $5.95

  • English Muffin with Cream Cheese, Peanut Butter & Strawberry Jam

    $5.95

  • Crispy Corn Polenta

    pomodoro sauce

    $5.25

  • Fruit Plate

    $7.25

  • Famous Noodle Kugel

    (full order)

    $7.95

Ice Cream

  • Hot Fudge Sundae

    vanilla or chocolate ice cream, valrhona fudge, candied walnuts, cherries

    $11.50

  • Noodle Kugel Sundae

    vanilla or chocolate ice cream, valrhona fudge, candied walnuts, cherries, our famous noodle kugel

    $13.95

  • Egg Cream

    chocolate or vanilla

    $7.50

  • Boylan's Root Beer Float

    chocolate or vanilla

    $10.50

  • Fountain Soda Float

    choice of soda & chocolate or vanilla ice cream

    $9.95

Milkshakes

  • The Morningside

    vanilla ice cream with fresh orange juice

    $11.95

  • The Shake & Wake

    vanilla ice cream, coffee, granola and strawberries

    $11.95

  • The Chocolatier

    chocolate ice cream, hot fudge, chocolate chips

    $11.95

  • The Sweet & Twisted

    vanilla ice cream, pretzel, chocolate chips

    $11.95

  • Classic

    chocolate, vanilla or black & white (make it a malt at no extra charge!)

    $9.95

powered by BentoBox